Content Editor ‭[1]‬

UNCLOS Arbitral Award​

Content Editor ‭[2]‬

​On 20 December 2010, Mauritius initiated arbitral proceedings against the UK under Article 287 and Annex VII of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) to challenge the legality of the ‘marine protected area’ (‘MPA’) which the UK purported to establish around the Chagos Archipelago on 1 April 2010.

​Following the exchange of written pleadings and the holding of a hearing on the merits and the UK’s preliminary objections to jurisdiction, the Arbitral Tribunal constituted under Annex VII to UNCLOS delivered its Award on 18 March 2015.  Pursuant to Article 11 of Annex VII to UNCLOS, the Award is final and without appeal, and binding on the Parties.

​The Tribunal unanimously held that the ‘MPA’ purportedly established by the UK around the Chagos Archipelago violates international law.  It ruled that the UK breached its obligations under Articles 2(3), 56(2) and 194(4) of UNCLOS.  

Two members of the Tribunal, namely Judge Kateka and Judge Wolfrum, gave a Dissenting and Concurring Opinion. In their Opinion, they held that:

(a)      ​​​the UK is not the “coastal State" in relation to the Chagos Archipelago;

(b)     internal UK documents suggested that there was an ulterior motive behind the 'MPA' and noted the disturbing similarities and common pattern between the establishment of the so-called “British Indian Ocean Territory" in 1965 and the proclamation of the 'MPA' in 2010;

(c)      the excision of the Chagos Archipelago from Mauritius in 1965 shows complete disregard for the territorial integrity of Mauritius by the UK;

(d)    ​UK Prime Minister Harold Wilson's threat to Premier Sir Seewoosagur Ramgoolam in 1965 that he could return home without independence if he did not consent to the excision of the Chagos Archipelago amounts to duress;

(e)   ​in 1965, Mauritian Ministers were coerced into agreeing to the detachment of the Chagos  Archipelago, and that this detachment violated the international law of self-determination; and

(f)     the 'MPA' is legally invalid.​

​​